Understanding Organic vs. Inorganic Storytelling in Games
In a reflective essay by Daniel Hunter Dowsing, a seasoned game writer-designer, the distinction between organic and inorganic storytelling in video games is explored to deepen our appreciation of narrative approaches within this evolving medium.
Defining Storytelling in Games
At its core, storytelling is about "change through conflict", where a protagonist driven by motivation confronts obstacles, experiences tension, reaches a climax, and ultimately undergoes transformation. Traditional narratives in other media (books, films, theater) each rely on unique languages—written words, visual framing, props, and images respectively—that are inherent and native to their form.
What is Organic Storytelling?
Organic storytelling is rooted in the language of the game medium itself—story elements emerge naturally from gameplay mechanics, player choices, and interactive environments, creating a seamless narrative experience. This approach respects the unique expressive potential of games and cultivates immersion by integrating story and play.
The Challenge of Inorganic Storytelling
In contrast, inorganic storytelling depends on narrative devices not native to games, such as cutscenes or supplementary materials outside the gameplay (e.g., novels bridging film chapters). For instance, cutscenes are cinematic sequences that employ film techniques like camera angles, acting, and editing. While appreciated for their polish and emotional impact, they interrupt gameplay flow and segment narrative delivery into passive viewing moments separate from interactive storytelling.
Dowsing does not dismiss cutscenes—he enjoys them and recognizes their artistic merit—but urges game writers to consider how reliance on such non-interactive storytelling can undermine narrative immersion by disconnecting story development from gameplay.
Case Study: Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver
A landmark example is Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver, noted for its engaging cutscenes enhancing the story of Raziel, a vampire protagonist wrestling with identity and betrayal. The game excels in inorganic storytelling through well-crafted cinematic moments, yet this also exemplifies how narrative and gameplay remain distinct rather than interwoven.
Games as a Young Medium Maturing its Narrative Language
Echoing the early days of cinema—initially recording simple scenes before evolving complex narrative languages—Dowsing suggests video games are currently maturing. As the industry experiments with diverse storytelling techniques, understanding and balancing organic and inorganic methods will be crucial in fully realizing games as a powerful cultural and artistic storytelling medium.
Key Takeaway:
For game developers and storytellers, appreciating the difference between organic (integrated gameplay-driven narrative) and inorganic (externally framed cinematic narrative) storytelling is essential. A mature narrative language in gaming will leverage both thoughtfully, enhancing player engagement while respecting the medium’s unique expressive capacity.
This reflection shines light on the nuanced relationship between narrative and gameplay, encouraging innovation for future game storytelling that harmonizes story and play within the interactive space.
Design Delight Studio curates high-impact, authoritative insights into sustainable and organic product trends, helping conscious consumers and innovative brands stay ahead in a fast-evolving green economy.
Leave a comment